Description

Built in 1881 bу Thomas Fagan and acclaimed architect Robert Dixon in the Neo Grec style, 165 St Johns Place (aka 44 7th Avenue) is a gorgeous 22-foot wide, 5-story corner brownstone in the heart of the original Park Slope Landmark District. This palatial townhouse was once home to Bill Engeman, who made his fortune selling horses to the Union Army during the Civil War and went on to build and operate the colossal Brighton Hotel in Coney Island. Originally designed as a single-family home on a grand scale, 165 St Johns Place is configured with five floor-through apartments, and will be delivered vacant.
Fifty-four windows facing south, east, and west bathe the interiors in natural light from dawn to dusk while framing storybook views of three majestic stone churches, with sweeping vistas stretching across Brooklyn and Manhattan beyond. This remarkable abundance of windows and triple exposure affords flexibility for a wide range of future uses, from a grand single-family residence to luxury condominium conversion and numerous other possibilities.
Coming home to 165 St Johns Place, you’ll walk up a tall stoop that sits high up off the street, and through beautifully carved wood doors. Arriving on the parlor floor, where the ceilings soar over 12-feet high, feels like stepping back in time to Brooklyn’s Gilded Age. Original details abound, including the original newel post and staircase, intricately carved walnut woodwork, pier mirrors, encaustic tile floors, magnificent pocket doors, plaster medallions, crown moldings, tin ceilings, and elegant marble fireplace mantles.
The garden level of 165 St Johns Place steps out at grade to a large wooded backyard which stretches over 44 feet deep and 28 feet across. This verdant oasis is a great place to relax, entertain, and enjoy everyday life. You’ll want to linger in this rare space and take in the cinematically stunning backdrop of St. John’s Church, with its stained glass, rusticated brownstone blocks, and gabled slate roof.
The basement at 165 St Johns Place runs the perimeter of the house and includes stately brick arches that are a testament to the quality craftsmanship that runs throughout the building.
165 St Johns Place is close to the best of Park Slope’s restaurants, shopping, and other amenities, with Grand Army Plaza, Prospect Park, and the Farmer’s Market nearby. The 2/3/B/Q subways are a block away, and many other transportation options are all easily accessible for a quick commute to Manhattan and the rest of the city. Come see this rare corner brownstone and explore the possibilities for your next chapter in Brooklyn.
View More

Building Features 4 Floors4 Units

intercom

Unit Features

Pet Policy: Building No, No

$5,750,000 / $1,004 per ft²

Listed on Jun 17, 2026

14 Days on Market

9 Beds / 5 Baths - / 5,726 ft²

Total Monthly expenses: $2,621

Maintenance: - / R.E. Taxes $2,621

Other Details:

Multi Family (4-6 Family)

Lot Size: 22.0' x 100.0' Built: 22.0' x 50.0'

Zoning: C2-3

Exclusively listed with: Compass Source: RLS

Paul M
Murphy

[email protected]

(718) 986-7509

Rebecca
Navarro

[email protected]

(585) 208-2945

Paul J
Pinizzotto

[email protected]

(917) 648-9628

Carol Kai-Ju
Wang

[email protected]

(347) 422-7652

Listing Courtesy of Compass View Listing

Unit listing history

Date Status Amount Listed by
Loading History...

Similar Listings for Sale

232 8 ST - Unit HOUSE

Park Slope / TOWNHOUSE

$5,995,000

On market for $5,995,000

0% from ask / 21 days on market

Monthly Expenses: $0

5 beds - 5 baths / 5318 ft²

363 4 ST - Unit HOUSE

Park Slope / TOWNHOUSE

$5,350,000

On market for $5,350,000

0% from ask / 24 days on market

Monthly Expenses: $0

- beds - 4 baths / 5456 ft²

676 UNION ST - Unit TH

Park Slope / TOWNHOUSE

$6,850,000

On market for $6,850,000

0% from ask / 141 days on market

Monthly Expenses: $0

6 beds - 4 baths / 6500 ft²

676 UNION ST - Unit HOUSE

Park Slope / TOWNHOUSE

$6,850,000

On market for $6,850,000

-5.52% from ask / 289 days on market

Monthly Expenses: $0

6 beds - 4 baths / 6500 ft²

531 1 ST - Unit HOUSE

Park Slope / TOWNHOUSE

$7,500,000

On market for $7,500,000

0% from ask / 71 days on market

Monthly Expenses: $0

7 beds - 4 baths / 4660 ft²

344 SEVENTH AVE - Unit HOUSE

Park Slope / TOWNHOUSE

$5,000,000

On market for $5,000,000

0% from ask / 974 days on market

Monthly Expenses: $0

- beds - - baths / 4680 ft²

135 FIFTH AVE - Unit HOUSE

Park Slope / TOWNHOUSE

$4,900,000

On market for $4,900,000

-10.89% from ask / 2154 days on market

Monthly Expenses: $0

- beds - - baths / 4800 ft²

295 SEVENTH AVE - Unit HOUSE

Park Slope / TOWNHOUSE

$4,600,000

On market for $4,600,000

0% from ask / 52 days on market

Monthly Expenses: $0

- beds - - baths / 4800 ft²