Get Out & Vote / Gold Advice Anyone?

Posted by Noah Rosenblatt on November 4, 2008 at 1.26 PM

A: Lines were crazy long this am, so I will try in an hour or so to go back and vote. Hopefully everyone is finding time to make it to vote today as well! In meantime, I want to ask readers for some help. I am in no way a gold bug, I'm not obsessed with it, and I don't revolve my life around it! But I do have a collector mentality (baseball cards / garbage pail kids / memorabilia have always interested me), and I do like gold on deleveraging dips considering the printing that is going on globally to combat this severe crisis. So, I did something nutty and bought my first piece of physical gold last week. Here is my experience, which I have little of, and hopefully someone out there can teach me more.

First off, I went to a few coin shops to check out buying American Eagle gold coins. I could not find any! From what I was told, these circulated gold coins are in huge demand and orders take time for delivery. When I went to FH Coin on Lexington Ave, I was told, "If I had any Eagles in, the line would be out the door within 24 hours to buy them...I expect an order to come in about 3 weeks from now". Of course this could have been BS! He did have Canadian Maple Leaf 1/oz gold coins that I could have bought for $815/each, some $65 over spot at the time. I didn't buy any.

GoldBarHundredGram.gifHonestly, I just wanted to mess around with like $2,500 and buy either Eagles or a gold bar. The more I researched the more I found out that the commissions to buy coins are much higher than the commissions to buy bars. So, I went downtown to a gold bullion dealer on Broad Street, named Manfra, Tordella & Brooks, Inc.. I didn't know anything about these guys except from what I see on the internet, but they were listed with the Better Business Bureau with no complaints filed and a satisfactory BBB rating, so I guess that's something.

As I walked into the lobby entrance, I had to take an elevator down to the basement; shady! But I guess it has to be downstairs where products are safely held in vaults. When I exited the elevator, there was a glass encased window between me and the bullion desk; kind of like at a a bank! Discussions of 1000/oz orders could be heard in the background making my intentions feel minuscule! Oh well, I'm just nibbling here as I am holding a bunch of gold etf's, physical is a whole new world to me! I figure if I can buy 2-3K worth each year and put it away, it can be a nice way to preserve some wealth if things get hairy. Of course if it does get hairy, I got way worse problems to worry about! I digress.

As I asked a million questions, the guy behind the desk started to give up and didn't have time to talk. Spot gold was at $744/oz, and he had only 2 gold bars left at the site. Both were 100g bars or 3.2125 ounces of 999.9% pure gold. The manufacturer was PAMP in Switzerland.

He would ONLY SELL ME ONE at the current spot price, and told me that if I wanted to buy more I would have to wire money into an account with them, lock in the spot price when I wanted to place the order, and wait 2-4 weeks for physical delivery. Ummmm, yea, not too enticing as I have no desire to buy lots of physical gold here.

I did buy the 100g PAMP Swiss Bar for $2,425, in cash as that was the only way they would do it, which came out to about $754 an ounce or about $10 over spot at the time of the deal. The rush I used to get as a kid when going to baseball card shows and buying a boxed set or a big name rookie card, returned! It lasted about 3 minutes. Since I already decided to buy something, I thought it was a way better a deal than paying more commission for Canadian Maple Leaf coins.

I don't know much about buying physical gold other than that there is not much of it around these days for us to buy at retailers, and that commissions are added and spreads wide between bid/ask. One thing I did make sure of is that the dealer would buy back the gold from me; which is a policy of this 57 year old dealer. The gold I bought is very similar to the picture above, its in my desk at home, with its assayer certificate (that I was told means nothing), and is kind of cool to look at!

I feel like a kid again. Anyway, just wanted to share my little gold buying experience with you and hopefully I don't come out as a super crackhead for doing so. If gold were to selloff more, I would get more interested in buying some more physical bars where commissions over spot are minimal; and just sock away. Of course, this is money I deem as unneeded and I would never put more than 5% or 7% of my total worth into physical gold.

Would love to hear from anyone out there who collects gold, about their experiences, what they learned, if I was ripped off at the time of the deal, where they do their deals, opinions on physical gold, etc..This is not meant as a prediction piece for gold! It is just to educate myself from readers who may have more experience in this sort of thing.

Thanks for any feedback.

Comments (17)

i dont think it's crazy. my father had some kruggerands that he gave to me and i have some american eagles too. i have no plans of selling though at this point.

Posted by paul.b | November 4, 2008 1:50 PM

Voting:
Make sure you know which Election District you belong to when going to vote in NYC or any other high population density area. You might as well take that election notification mailer that was sent to your address. My voting station was for 3 districts, so if you didn't remember which one, finding it out was chaos. Call 1-866-OUR-VOTE (866-687-8683) and select 1 if you need someone to match your address to a district.

Posted by Nobi | November 4, 2008 1:59 PM

Mine was PS6 - 15 min wait.

Go here to check where your district is.

http://www.rockthevote.com/

Posted by Noah | November 4, 2008 2:34 PM

If I wanted to take physical delivery of gold, I would go long a 100oz futures contract on NYMEX and take it into delivery. Once delivered, you can generally get the certificate from your Futures Commission Merchant. With the certificate, you can take delivery from the depository or you can just leave it in the depository. If you take it out, it will have to be asseyed before the depository will accept it, but note that it will be in a form acceptable for delivery into a contract, while bullion bought at retail will probly not, unless you have been quite careful to buy to meet the contract specification. There will be fees for all of this. However your spread will be far better on NYMEX than in some retail dealers basement. If you want to do something like this, be clear with your FCM that this is what you are intending to do. Not all are prepared to take physical delivery, as this is fairly rare. And you should understand all the fees that will be associated with taking physical delivery.

Posted by jrd | November 4, 2008 7:31 PM

THANKS jrd!

Posted by Noah | November 4, 2008 8:19 PM

Will they buy back the bar without a new assay? I would think this may be prohibitively expensive.

Posted by nick v | November 5, 2008 1:14 PM

Nick v - dont know. But they will buy the bar I bought from them back.

Thats all I know. Sorry

Posted by Noah | November 5, 2008 3:16 PM

Noah,

Thanks for the response, it sounds like they'll buy back your specific bar without a new assay which seems reasonable. Also, MTB is a licensed depository for NYMEX contracts, so I would imagine they are 100% legit.

Posted by nick v | November 5, 2008 6:07 PM

I was reading this real estate blog! And it had an article about voting! And also about buying physical gold! But even more than that! It had a lot of exclamation points!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by john haskell | November 6, 2008 4:04 PM

Hey Noah, how's it going?

http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article6952.html

stay far away futures contracts. there is much talk about investors taking delivery in DEC causing the paper exchange to default.

Posted by Sang | November 6, 2008 5:55 PM

Noah, not that I have a "lot" of experience but I always buy my gold online where the prices are much, much closer to spot also you get a way better selection. Personally I sold all my gold early last year as I saw it zooming up and for a 2 year investment it worked well. Since its been a while since I was a buyer I'm not 100% sure how different the speads are currently online as it has been a while since I ordered any.

Posted by Michael Oliver | November 8, 2008 9:02 PM

michael - who do you buy from online? Thanks. I think gold will fall because everyone wants it now and that usually is contrarian indicator. But if it does go to 550-600. I would want in!

Posted by Noah | November 9, 2008 8:26 AM

I buy from APMEX.com never had any issues. Ya I also agree mid 500's is all good for buying.

Posted by Michael Oliver | November 10, 2008 6:41 PM

I have been buying here from a company called bullion trading llc. The service is good & their prices are great. I don't know about other places but these guys are the people that the guys on 47Th street buy from.
Anyway I want to keep my money in gold rather then in the banks at this point!!!!

Posted by John | January 22, 2009 2:31 PM

Thanks for the great reading, we buy gold bullion in a recession. I will pass this on to our ira clients to read.

Posted by goldcoinsgain | October 29, 2009 2:18 AM

The Canadian Gold Maple Leaf has been traded on the world market since 1979, thanks for the post.

Posted by Gold Coins Canadian | January 22, 2010 7:04 AM

The Gold Canadian Maple Leaf is a very beautifully designed gold coin and I just got one,

Posted by Canadian Gold Coins | January 22, 2010 7:06 AM

Post a comment


To help maintain the integrity of the conversation we ask that each user simply paste the keyword (below in red) into the confirmation field below. Sorry, but if you forget this step, your comments will not be saved!