SF Fed President Yellen Talks Dovish
A: I'm taking some time off from real estate this month and watching all that is happening in the stock market & credit world. A little disclosure, I did re-activate my trading account to get a more real time look at what is going on daily in the equity markets; screenshot at bottom of this post of my trading software and what I see (mapping keys right now so positions are minimal for testing). Some breaking statements from SF Fed President Janet Yellen, to me, hints at the reality that a RATE CUT is more likely than a hike as the next move. UD readers know that I have been in the dovish side for a while now, after acknowledging that wage inflation and an expansion in the money supply is not the type of inflation that is threatening us this time around. Rather, its credit/housing deflation that pose that biggest threats to our economy.
For much of 2007 I was focused on how commodity price inflation was not being measured properly and that our fed would be stuck in between a rock and a hard place with rates, due to soaring commodity prices and a weakening economy. I thought a rate hike campaign was inevitable at some point, but just unsure of its start date. But towards the end of the year and into early 2008, I got way more serious about the effects of deflation on our economy and got more dovish; specifically, credit & housing deflation occurring at the same time as soaring commodity inflation. For the past few months, I have been purely dovish in regards to future fed policy, expecting a rate cut and not a hike, likely in response to a market event.
Let me go into what Yellen just stated first, and explain how this fits perfectly into the school of thought that I have been in for most of 2008.
"Q3 GDP WILL NOT HOLD UP"
"FED POLICY MUST BE CALIBRATED TO PUSH THROUGH THE SUBSTANTIAL HEADLINES OUR ECONOMY IS FACING"
"FALLING COMMODITY PRICES HELPING THE FED"
"CREDIT CRUNCH IS DEEPENING"
"NO EVIDENCE OF WAGE PRICE SPIRAL"
Does this sound like a hawkish fed to you if this mindset is shared among other fed members, specifically, voting fed members? Yellen is an alternate voting member of the fed. Her comments perfectly fit into the thought process that ultra high commodity prices and a very weak dollar is NOT the environment hoped for to proceed with stimulative monetary or fiscal policy. And I think monetary policy will have to be stimulative as we face the economic after-effects of this year long credit hurricane and 3 year housing slowdown.
Almost a month ago, I wrote 'A Thought on the Dollar' and stated very clearly where I stand:
"By giving the dollar a boost without actually hiking rates in US or cutting rates in Eurozone, it will give our fed MORE FREEDOM TO CUT RATES should our economy continue to deteriorate down the road.I stated my dovish stance on AUG 5th, when almost everyone else out there was still betting on a rate hike as the next move.
Ben wants to inflate, and in my opinion will not hike rates as long as there is housing/credit deflation, unemployment is rising, and the financial sector remains under distress. Hiking rates now will be counter-productive to fixing the financials/credit markets (which is so crucial for a housing recovery to take place) and an orderly unwind of toxic securities.
An outcome supported by this way of thinking, is if our fed does indeed cut rates as their next move (who knows when), and if Trichet holds rates at 4.25% for the foreseeable future. Should this happen, then the fed orchestrated it wonderfully..."
"In meantime, I think the fed is talking tough about inflation and may have to cut rates before raising them should the credit markets / housing markets continue to deteriorate OR if an event occurs to stabilize markets before trading re-opens; so I'm more on the dovish side while I see Barry Ritholtz on the hawkish side."Lets see how this plays out. My money is on an inter-meeting rate cut in co-ordination with intervention to an 'event', to alleviate the shock to the tradable markets before opening. I just dont see the cut coming at a planned meeting. What I would consider an 'event' would be similar to the rescue of Bear Stearns. The most likely events we face are to rescue the GSEs, failure of another top IB such as Lehman or Merrill, failure of a top bank such as WaMu or Wachovia, and such.
We know some big names will fail and the world as we know it is in the process of changing. Lets get it on already!!
Trading Software: I was an equities trader at Tradescape from 1998-2004, after following the tradable markets from the ripe old age of 13; a $250 failed investment in SGI got me hooked. The company was bought by E-Trade, taken private, and now operating as LightSpeed Trading. I find the software fine for the active trader and ticket prices are about $6 per 1,000 shares (or ticket as I call it). I'll vouch for the software for any traders out there who are unhappy with their current trading systems.




Posted by anonymous
Fri Sep 5th, 2008 09:14 PM
Dear Noah,
I've really enjoyed your blog for about 18 months now; some weeks I check in daily (when I'm procrastinating). I don't often post comments, but this entry seemed to confirm especially clearly an impression I've had for several months now: this is no longer really a real estate blog. My impression is that your interests lie in economics, with economic implications for real estate as an active but less prominent area. And you yourself seem to have come to the same conclusion. Will you be starting a separate blog and release this blog to matters that more directly pertain to NY real estate? I hope so. Good luck.
Posted by Noah
Sat Sep 6th, 2008 09:47 AM
anonymous - I think you hit it perfectly. Im a trader, through and through, I still trade, and real estate is a second passion of mine, but not first.
What can I say. This site is more my daily journal of macro economic thoughts/opinions and what the implications may have on Manhattan real estate. In addition, I like to discuss strategies for investing in Manhattan real estate, which I did plenty of prior to the start of this credit crisis mid last year. The articles are still there and can still apply.
Heres the catch. To write daily or even weekly on Manhattan real estate and not sacrifice the quality of the content has proven to be EXTREMELY HARD. Put simply, manhattan real estate doe snot change daily, or even weekly. Confidence may change fast, but not general trends. We dont have quick ups and quick downs in inventory, nor do we have prices changing drastically from week to week. So, content gets stale if focused primarily on real estate. After writing daily for 2 years or so, I just found myself running out of fresh new content that lived up to the quality standards that I want for this site.
I have not really thought about starting a new blog and releasing this for strictly Manhattan real estate. If I did, I think you would be upset with the content. It would be more fluff than analytical and educational.
Its something I struggled with over the course of the past year or so. So, I decided to make this site macro economic discussions with a change of pace via investment strategies for Manhattan real estate that include, state of the market, inventory trends, confidence trends, currency trends, or whatever may or may not be occurring that affects this housing market at any given time.
Unfortunately, change is slow and non frequent. I hope you re-read this comment thread so you see this response. I thank you for bringing it up and telling me where you would like to see the focus. I just dont have the passion for discussing real estate daily, when we are in the current environment with so much more to talk about that I feel ultimately will affect this market.
Perhaps I need to adjust the mission statement of this site. I know I may lose readers, but in the end, you have to discuss what your are passionate about and what you are interested in if its on your own time and not a paying job. For me, that is macro, credit markets, equity markets, state of our economy, and then real estate.
My clients in real estate use me for my consulting regarding their sale or their investment in a new home. I am not a salesman, and I dont BS people. Not the best characteristics of the typical real estate agent whose job is to always be selling, and to sell sell sell and always paint a rosy picture. I tell it like it is, and its this brutal honesty that I find my clients come to me for.
In the end, I do not see myself as a real estate agent down the road, in say 3-5 years. Rather I will likely do something with UrbanDigs brand and/or some type of real estate investment consulting company to help make NYC real estate more transparent and analytical for that target audience, or go back into wall street/hedge fund in some capacity. Sorry if this disappoints you, as I respect and love my readers. They motivated me to maintain this site and I dont like to disappoint. But in the end, passion is what drives me and now you know for sure where my passion is.
For urbandigs, Im not done with the project and I want this site to have the tools capable of changing the process of investing in Manhattan real estate for the better. Everything can be perfected, and the way business is done here has many flaws. I want to re-introduce savvy into investing here. I want it more transparent. So in that sense, this site will continue to grow.
Thanks.
Posted by Noah
Sat Sep 6th, 2008 09:57 AM
PS: I tried many many times to get more writers to this site that would contribute content from the front lines of Manhattan real estate. It has proven VERY difficult. That to me is the ideal fix. Sure the writing style is different, and opinion different, but I just cant seem to find any agent willing to devote time to writing about what they see on the front lines, a few times a week.
There is just no interest. Sucks.
Posted by Homes Miami Lakes for Sale
Wed Apr 28th, 2010 01:44 AM
Fantastic real estate blog post! Pictures are worth thousands of words, it’s nice to see the attention to detail from your end. Thanks
Posted by 1800 Club Condos
Sat Jun 12th, 2010 06:29 AM
Real very good real estate blog I have ever seen. Good going, Keep it up