Big Data, Big Fed Day
A: We got some mixed data today via a stronger than expected jobs report and a weaker than expected GDP report. What does it all mean? Besides a slowing economy, who the hell knows as both these reports are likely to get revised later on anyway. How does it affect the fed? Who the hell knows what helicopter Ben & Co. will do later today. All I know is, it's going to be a wild ride for a while.
I should clear up one major thing for readers here. The worries that I have and which I publicly discuss, are fueled by a national housing slump and the resulting fall in securities that come from it. Thats it. Should housing stabilize across the nation, inventories start to fall, sales volume pickup, and defaults/delinquencies go lower you will see alot of the problems we currently face go away. It's perfectly clear that the fed, the gov't and the private sector is doing everything they can to inject liquidity, aggressively ease monetary policy, push an economic stimulus plan and bail out the troubled institutions so that credit markets can operate normally again. Outside of housing, financial turmoil, and dysfunctional credit markets, the US & Global economies are fairly strong.
What remains to be seen is HOW housing, financial turmoil, and dysfunctional credit markets ultimately hit both our economy and economies abroad. Hence, the proactive stimulus. America's well known debt problem finally faces the fire and what we are dealing with here is a fuel (housing slump) that was leveraged up the wazoo! How will other debt classes be hit in the future and will the stimulus be enough to save us?
On to the economic data. Checking in on the jobs report, we got some positive news although future revisions can always occur later on. According to Marketwatch.com:
Employment in the U.S. private sector grew by 130,000 jobs in January, according to the ADP employment report released Wednesday. Adding in some 25,000 government jobs typically added but not covered by the ADP report, it suggests non-farm payrolls grew by about 155,000 in January. This is much faster than the 70,000 economists expected before the report.The more important measure of how our economy grew in the 4th quarter, the GPD (advance) number came in well below expectations. According to Bloomberg:
The U.S. economy weakened more than forecast in the fourth quarter as housing sank deeper into recession and consumer spending cooled.The GDP number clearly was the more important number to the markets today. Now, the fed makes its decision on rates at 2:15, and I got to say there are wide thoughts on what may be done!Economic growth slowed to an annual rate of 0.6 percent in October through December, half the rate forecast, following a 4.9 percent pace the previous three months, the Commerce Department said today in Washington. Residential construction dropped by the most in 26 years.
Housing slumped as subprime lending collapsed and financial markets seized up, putting the six-year expansion at risk. The economy was forecast to expand at a 1.2 percent pace, according to the median estimate of 77 economists surveyed by Bloomberg News.
CUT 1/2 ---> Economy needs the insurance and aggressive ease to ensure that we do not fall into recession.
CUT 1/4 ---> Fed just cut 75 bps last Tuesday in an emergence rate cut that appeared as a panic move as global markets plunged. Turns out, the selloff was blamed on a rogue trader at SocGen. Yea right! No way he pulled this off by himself under the radar of top level exec's, but hey, its an easy way to move blame from bad bets to fraudulent trader.
NO CUT ---> Fed trying to regain control over the tradable markets. Site commodity inflation risks. Inflation gauge in GDP report showed a huge increase in core inflation from 2% to 2.7% in 4th quarter. Hmm, you mean today's world is more expensive than 5 years ago? I didn't notice! Ehh, lets just inflate our way out of this mess anyway.
I hate to say it, but given the weak GDP and fear that the markets will plunge on no cut, I think the fed will make a move today. I'm just not sure if it will be 1/4 or a 1/2. Your thoughts? I'm going with 1/4. Stocks will likely selloff with anything but 50 bps.
I still think we need to let a recession fix the problems we are in, let the private sector consolidate the financials and clean out the books, let the credit markets fix themselves, and let housing prices fall enough so that affordability kicks in bringing real buyers to the marketplace to bring brighter times ahead without inflation problems! My worst fear is that the fed over stimulates, re-inflates assets, the problems eventually turn out to be not as bad as feared, and then they will have to take back the rate cuts down the road to curb runaway inflation.


Comments (11)
I vote he cuts 1/2 markets soar
Posted by heli ben | January 30, 2008 1:02 PM
your not alone heli! Someone call my cell with the move! I'm off to showings. GO GOLD!
Posted by Noah | January 30, 2008 1:08 PM
Don't fight the Fed Noah because that is one mean-looking big ass gorilla. That gorilla is going to do whatever it takes to squash that recession.
Posted by Steve | January 30, 2008 2:22 PM
50 bps. Once again, there should never have been any doubt.
Posted by Colgin | January 30, 2008 2:29 PM
looking at the 10 year treasury yield after the cut, it seems the bond market has FINALLY noticed the FED is fanning inflation..
ironically, these cuts could have the effect of spiking mortgage rates!
Posted by uwsider | January 30, 2008 2:43 PM
Noah asked me to write this on his behalf. He said he was about to go into the subway and a $100 bill fell from a bldg and into his hand.
what the hell does that mean?
Posted by Noah | January 30, 2008 2:57 PM
uwsider..."fanning inflation" that is what you want...if...you own.
Posted by Anonymous | January 30, 2008 3:25 PM
This is the real Noah, and it was two $100 bills that fell from the sky!
Anyway, WOW, GREAT JOB, it saved the markets a whopping 35 pts as I see it right now. Still 20 min left in day though. Sounds like more wasted ammo and the fed acknowledging the severity of problems in housing/financials.
Not much they can do though, as all this is to soothe the pain later on and stimulate growth in years to come. Problems still need to be worked out on their own.
Gold baby!
Posted by Noah | January 30, 2008 3:40 PM
All major indices finished down on the day. Expect special super duper emergency stock prop up . . .er. . . additional rate cut tomorrow morning pre-open. :)
Posted by Colgin | January 30, 2008 4:57 PM
ha! Bond insurer downgrades woke the street up to the fact that even in the face of rate cuts, big problems lie under the surface!
Posted by Noah | January 30, 2008 5:18 PM
steve steve steve! There are reasons the fed is acting so aggressively. After the initial jolt and ammo is used up, the street will realize that things are bad out there! It will take time. Yes, in year or two the fed cuts will stimulate another boom somewhere, buts housing we are dealing with and debt. And you cant have a bull rally without the financials!
Still problems under the surface! 5 years of lax lending, no underwriting, ultra low rates, awful bets and a unsustainable housing boom. 7 months will not fix that problem! We need time!
Posted by Noah | January 30, 2008 6:20 PM