2007 - Predictions & Discussions
A: I thought it might be fun to lay a few predictions down, being the first business day of 2007, so that at the end of the year we can all look back and see how wrong I really was! Well, hopefully not too wrong but who is ever right on the money all the time right! So, here are some of my thoughts on everything economic, including NYC housing predictions. Would love to hear your thoughts!
NOTE - This is really just for the sake of discussions and nothing I mention here should be used to place investments on unless you discuss first with your financial advisor. Please take what I say here as my opinion based on data that I currently see. The real point is to provoke discussions to hear others' thoughts on what 2007 might bring.

Will The Economy Have A Soft-Landing in 2007 - Lets start out with the toughest call; the US economy. With the stock market predicting a soft landing and the bond market predicting a coming recession, who is right? For now, I'm going with the stock market.
My Prediction - The US economy will prove its resilience once again as corporate profits continue to be strong, but NOT as strong as previously predicted by the equity markets. I expect wages and jobs to come under a bit of pressure; especially in housing related industry's where job losses will skew the overall national jobs numbers downward. Wages will stabilize but for the most part remain strong as 2007 proves to be another good year for stocks; just not as good as 2006. I would think 8-10% gains in major indexes for the full year as long as nothing crazy happens with energy prices or unexpected unnatural disasters. The end of the year might prove worst for the US economy as housing related consumer spending cutbacks may prove real.
The Wild Card - Housing & Energy. If housing is worse than expected or energy prices shoot higher expect stocks to come under pressure.
Will Energy Prices Soar & Hurt Economic Growth in 2007 - No, I dont think so. I actually think the price of energy will fall a bit over the course of the year as a warmer than expected winter ends and a less than expected hurricane season occurs. This is all just a guess of course, but why not make a stab at it.
My Prediction - Oil will be trading closer to $50/barrel by the end of 2007 and possibly lower. Geopolitical tensions prove to be better than expected and Iraq continues to get more pipeline on-line throughout the year, adding to the global supply. OPEC's planned oil production cuts prove very hard to enforce. If this proves true, its one less inflationary pressure to worry about giving stocks and the economy a bit more upside.
The Wild Card - Geo-political tensions & Weather. Should Iran, Nigeria, or Iraq have more issues the price of oil will likely shoot higher. Also, if weather gets much colder or we have a very active hurricane season, oil prices will stay at higher levels.
NYC Housing Market in 2007 - Which is why you are all here right.
My Prediction - I expect a slight increase in activity in the months of JAN - MARCH which is proven mid year by lagging housing data reports on deals during this timeframe. Remember that housing data is lagging. I wouldn't be surprised if housing shows some price gains during these months as well as an uptick in sales volume.
During the course of the summer I worry that economic jobs data might come in lower than expected, putting some pressure on housing as this industry still searches for a bottom. Activity will again slow during the summer months and desperate sellers will once again have to negotiate more than expected to move a property. Overall, by the end of 2007, I expect NYC housing to experience a decline of about 3-5% or so as fundamentals continue to correct for longer term sustainable growth. If the first few months prove to show gains of 1-2% in prices, then the summer months and remaining months of 2007 will show a wipe-out of these gains plus a few more percentage points.
Should economic data come in weaker than expected in jobs and wages, I would expect housing to suffer for a bit longer than expected with sharper movements.
Keep close eyes on lenders during this time to see if banks tighten the noose of easy credit! Should this occur, as a result of a slowing economy (job losses and downward wage pressure), housing could be in for a bigger slump than previously expected and might last for a few years longer until an outside force (such as monetary policy) stimulates buyer demand again.
All in all, I expect a slightly down year for NYC housing prices with activity staying stable as lower prices and deals attract more buyers. Put simply, the fundamental of 'negotiability' as experienced in buyers' markets, will show itself in data during the course of 2007. You can't have a market where there is widespread negotiating and still show solid gains in pricing at the same time! That would be a paradox.
The Wild Card - JOBS & LENDERS. In my mind the two biggest threats to housing's continued mission to find a bottom! If job losses are higher than expected or banks tighten lending requirements (making borrowing harder to lock in), housing will suffer more than expected and could see a very volatile year in price declines and inventory levels.
What The Fed Will Do in 2007 - For the most part, stay where they are! I keep swinging my thoughts on whether the fed will hike or cut rates during the course of the year because it really is data dependent. Fact is, I dont know what the inflation data will be nor do I know what the stock market will do or what might affect oil prices during the course of the year. All of these things play a role in whether or not the fed will hike or ease.
My Prediction - Im going to play it conservatively and say that at the end of 2007 the fed funds futures will be either the same or at 5%; down 1/4 point from where we are today. I'm going to bet that inflation pressures continue to ease with the correction of energy prices allowing the fed to focus on economic expansion issues that may arise. If jobs and wages show weaker than expected numbers, partly as a result of weaker housing, than the fed might ease a bit to psycholgically stimulate the economy. But this can very quickly change if inflation data comes in higher than expected. I'll certainly continue my anaylsis of this here on UrbanDigs.com.
The Wild Card - Inflation & US Dollar. If core PCE or PPI shows more inflation pressure than expected, and the US dollar continues its downard slide, the fed could RAISE rates putting more pressure on holders of debt and making it more expensive to borrow! As we all know, the more expensive it is to borrow, the less affordable housing becomes and the result is lower buyer demand both in the size of the buyer pool, speculative investors, and what buyers can ultimately afford. Very important to keep your eyes on these things!



Comments (12)
housing will fall 7-10% and stocks will have an off year...why do you think oil will fall?
Commodities will increase further making inflation a problem. Bernanke is later seen as being wrong and should have raised rates more earlier
Posted by anon | January 2, 2007 12:30 PM
anon - I think oil will correct some more in 2007. Weather is unseasonably warm in NE and if this continues, or even if it only gets cold for a short while, then inventories would have run up even more causing a slowdown in demand...plus it seems geopolitical tensions have been relatively upbeat in past few months. No news is good news on this front..
Going with the trend..we might have a short term rise, but overall I think oil will correct more in 2007..I hope so at least...
Posted by Noah | January 2, 2007 12:49 PM
Oil will go higher. We are competing with Europe and Asia for oil and if you haven't noticed our currency is taking a nosedive. WIth no end in sight as of yet.
If that nosedive continues out of control inflation will hit and yes real estate can still go a lot higher.
Posted by London Aparmetments | January 2, 2007 7:15 PM
London Apartments - you raise very good points and they are difficult to argue. For sake of this discussion Im going to stick to lower oil in 2007. I think the last year of high oil put into motion many business model changes in oil supply and I think the lack of news out of the middle east combined with a warmer than expected winter in USA will combine to increase inventory and prices to fall going into summer months...
Thanks for commenting.
Posted by Noah | January 2, 2007 8:26 PM
Hey,
You are NOT an ECON major. Please do not try to tell us where the market is going. Just focus on showing us a studio for rent or sale. That is what you are good for. If I want an ECON opinion I will ask someone who is an expert. YOU are NOT an eXPERT.
Posted by jack | January 3, 2007 12:16 AM
jack - then stop reading my blog! Did you miss the note on top that the point of this was to provoke conversations and to hear others thoughts on what the year might bring.
I dont need to explain my education, my past job, or my thoughts on why I think this stuff is important to discuss when it comes to real estate investments.
If you want to find a studio for rent or a 1BR to buy, go to streeteasy.com. Thats NOT the point of this blog! The point of this blog is to discuss the fundamentals of real estate investing, monetary policy, economic data, renovation tips, what to spend your money on, etc..
Posted by Noah | January 3, 2007 8:39 AM
Jack - and another thing...I did listen to the economic experts back in 2000 when about 95% said that the internet revolution made stock prices STILL SEEM CHEAP compared with what future earnings were going to bring.
And I also trusted the reports that the companies were disclosing to me as I read them to decide whether or not to keep the investment. Little did I know that these so-called epxerts were TOTALLY WRONG and that the company's data being disclosed were COMPLETE LIES that were later revised AFTER the stocks tanked and losses ensued.
Just curious your thoughts on this? Or were you not invested at that time and therefore havent lived through the pain that listening to experts brought to so many people.
Posted by Noah | January 3, 2007 9:09 AM
Jack:
You are a dope and if you don't want the info, go read another blog.
Noah - as always, thanks for the good info. As to wild cards - lenders will be suffering some more pain in the coming year and it will have some effect on the on the overall market.
Stephanie
Posted by Stephanie | January 3, 2007 2:04 PM
Noah - I am not trying to predict changes in the oil market. I think you misunderstood my point about oil. Nor do I know which way things are going. My point is Keep your Eye on the Dollar.
Oil is almost a currency. Look at the USD vs. EURO or YUAN or GREAT BRITAIN POUND. The USD has declined by about 35% vs all major currencies since the war in Iraq Started.
The Declining US Dollar is raising the price of oil because USD is no longer worth what it was to the countries you buy oil from. Declines in the US Dollar = Higher Oil prices.
Consider this.... in 2002 when Oil was $40 and the Euro was $0.80 Oil was 52 Euros. Today oil is 60 and the Euro is $1.30 Oil is now only 49 Euros.
If the USD goes back up to where it was oil will be $37 per barrel without ever moving. On the flipside if the USD declines another 35% oil can go to $100 without any changes in the oil market.
If USD continues to decline the price of Oil in US Dollars will skyrocket creating rapid inflation throughout the United States and this can make real estate go even higher.
Posted by London Apartments | January 4, 2007 1:51 AM
London Apts - Ahh, yes I think I did misunderstand. Very good points you are making still. Question is, what if the US Dollar basically ends the year unchanged or slightly changed.
Don't you think oil can still correct even without the currency valuations or lack of bounce in US Dollar cheapening the price of oil?
Excluding currency aspect, I think oil will correct this year to about $47-$50/barrel or so. But as you say, if US Dollar continues to decline, this theory goes out the window.
Posted by Noah | January 4, 2007 9:38 AM
I believe this one applies "Unless each man prodiuses more than he receives, increases his output, there will be less for him than all the others", doesn't it?
Posted by Hayley Feehan | May 28, 2007 5:50 PM
Yes, you are absolutely right.
But what are the predictions for 2009? I guess it can't get much worse, can it? I can't even afford to get New York Show Tickets and want to go so badly.
Posted by Michael Minstor | February 1, 2009 11:31 AM